Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Weddings · Advice & Questions ·

Our audio guestbook was meant for us. My sister wants to play the messages at brunch the next day.

Weddings category photographWeddings

We are hiring a telephone-style audio guestbook for our wedding. The greeting we recorded says, “Leave us a message to listen to when we’re home.” We imagined hearing little bits of advice, jokes and congratulations privately after the weekend.

My sister is arranging a casual brunch the next morning. She wants to play a selection of the recordings and make a highlights video for the family afterwards. She says people will only say nice things, and a shared playback would be a lovely way to end the celebrations.

I would enjoy hearing some messages with everyone, but that is a different audience from the one our greeting suggests. We have not held the wedding yet, so we can still change the wording or the plan. My partner thinks explaining all the possible uses will make a fun guestbook feel like a form nobody wants to complete.

How should we describe what happens to the recordings? Would you keep the guestbook private, ask separately before sharing particular clips, or make the wider audience clear from the start?

Discussion

5 community replies

Choose the intended audience before recording a new greeting. At the moment you have one plan and your sister has added two more uses. If you want private messages, tell her there will be no brunch playback. You do not need to offer a larger audience just because she has thought of a cheerful way to use the recordings.

A short greeting can set an honest expectation without becoming a long set of conditions. “These messages are just for us to listen to at home” is clear if that is the plan. If you want a public montage instead, guests should know that before deciding what to say or whether to use the phone.

“Only nice things” does not settle it. A loving message can still feel personal, especially if it names someone, tells a private story or sounds different when cut into a compilation. The relevant question is whether the speaker would be comfortable with that particular use, rather than whether your sister expects the words to be flattering.

If you hear a clip you later want to share, ask the person about that clip and the proposed audience then. Let them say no without having to justify it. That seems more manageable than promising a highlights video in advance and then feeling pressure to find enough messages to fill it.

Asking about the actual clip would also let the person hear what you mean to share, rather than agreeing to an unknown edit. Keep the original private while you ask. Your sister can still organise brunch without having a finished audio programme promised to her.

Join the discussion

More in Weddings