Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

Our ARM notice shows a higher rate, but we have been reading the cap differently

Housing category photographHousing

Our US adjustable-rate mortgage is approaching its first adjustment after the fixed period. The servicer has sent a notice showing the new rate and payment. My partner says the loan's rate cap should prevent the increase shown; I think he has been reading the cap for later adjustments as if it also sets the first one.

The CFPB describes separate initial, subsequent and lifetime adjustment caps. I can follow the distinction in the explanation, but I am not confident about matching it to our signed documents and this notice.

We had talked casually about refinancing before this point and never made a firm plan. Now the discussion jumps straight from 'the notice must be wrong' to 'we have to refinance', without either of us understanding the payment in front of us.

What should we ask the servicer to walk us through so we can check the adjustment and plan around a confirmed obligation?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for the calculation in writing, including the contractual inputs used and the effective dates for the rate and payment. If something still does not reconcile, identify that exact difference when you follow up. You will get further with 'show us this step' than with trying to settle the whole disagreement from the headline payment.

Set aside a separate conversation about the refinancing you had hoped to do. Request actual terms before comparing it with keeping the existing loan. Regretting an earlier plan does not tell you what a new offer would cost or establish that the current notice is wrong.

So is the lifetime cap just the rate we should put in the household budget from now on, to be on the safe side?

Join the discussion

More in Housing