Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

Our 'anonymous' team survey asks for my position, and I'm the only goalkeeper. What can I ask before giving feedback?

Sports category photographSports

The survey doesn't ask for a name. It does require our playing position, and I'm the only goalkeeper in a six-person training group. The coach has asked everyone to be frank because the responses are anonymous.

I have specific feedback about how keeper practice is arranged. I'm willing to discuss it, but I don't want to write under an assurance that doesn't seem to fit the form. I also don't know who sees the raw answers or what will be shared with the coach.

We're in the UK. The ICO's anonymisation guidance explains that removing names may still leave enough context to identify someone. I'm not claiming this particular survey is unlawful; I'm questioning what anonymity can realistically mean here.

How would you ask the club to clarify the process and choose a feedback route? I'd like the training issue addressed without either supplying false position information or becoming a public example of a dissatisfied player.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask who receives the raw answers, whether position is necessary, and what form of feedback reaches the coach. The form's lack of a name field doesn't answer those questions. You can raise the obvious goalkeeper example without submitting your detailed feedback as a test.

Even if the position question disappeared, the story of a unique keeper session might still identify you. The ICO guidance emphasises context and possible identification, so be wary of treating one deleted field as a guarantee.

If you are comfortable being identified to a suitable person, a confidential conversation may fit better than an anonymous form. Ask how that conversation would be handled before sharing details. Confidentiality also needs an honest explanation of who may need to receive the concern.

Taking every identifying detail out could leave the coach with "some training could be better" and no useful action. I wouldn't want the only advice to be so vague that the keeper problem survives unchanged.

Choose the channel with that trade-off in mind. You may be able to give a precise account to an appropriate person who explains how it will be used, while asking that unnecessary identifying details aren't circulated. Don't promise yourself complete anonymity and complete specificity if the actual process can't provide both.

Join the discussion

More in Sports