Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

One replacement card has a different back. How do we keep our board-game deck fair?

Gaming category photographGaming

The replacement card reached the top of the deck, and everyone knew what was coming. Its back was a different shade from the originals.

The host had made a temporary replacement after losing a card. It keeps the deck complete, but drawing the next card is supposed to involve information we don't have yet. Once we'd noticed the back, pretending not to recognize it wasn't much of a solution.

Nobody is accusing the host of trying to win. He wants to use his game, and we don't want to mark or alter his original cards. We haven't checked whether a cover or another agreed replacement would remain recognizable by its size or edges.

What would you try before continuing? I'd like a fix that preserves the intended uncertainty and the deck's contents, without making everyone spend the evening proving that they can forget the card they saw.

Discussion

5 community replies

Name the visible problem and pause before another draw. The replacement can have been made in good faith while still changing the information available. You don't need a claim about anyone's intentions to address that.

If you try opaque covers, test the whole arrangement rather than only the color on the back. A replacement that remains obvious by its size or edge hasn't resolved the issue you described. Get the owner's agreement before changing any components.

Check the card count and contents after any substitution. A solution to the visible back shouldn't quietly add, omit or duplicate a card. Work from the game's actual component information instead of relying on memory.

If no suitable repair is available that evening, play something else and revisit the deck later. Continuing with a known card is a house variant the table could choose, but it shouldn't be presented as restoring the original uncertainty.

That variant needs everyone's understanding before play resumes. Don't ask people to ignore information and then criticize them for choices that reflect it. Either agree on the changed game or wait until you have a replacement the table accepts.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming