One replacement card has a different back. How do we keep our board-game deck fair?
GamingThe replacement card reached the top of the deck, and everyone knew what was coming. Its back was a different shade from the originals.
The host had made a temporary replacement after losing a card. It keeps the deck complete, but drawing the next card is supposed to involve information we don't have yet. Once we'd noticed the back, pretending not to recognize it wasn't much of a solution.
Nobody is accusing the host of trying to win. He wants to use his game, and we don't want to mark or alter his original cards. We haven't checked whether a cover or another agreed replacement would remain recognizable by its size or edges.
What would you try before continuing? I'd like a fix that preserves the intended uncertainty and the deck's contents, without making everyone spend the evening proving that they can forget the card they saw.