Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

My tennis opponent wants a phone app to overrule our line calls. What should we agree before the next match?

Sports category photographSports

“The app says it was in,” my opponent said, holding up a replay from a phone positioned behind the fence. I'd called his rally ball out at my end. We hadn't agreed to use that app as a review system, and neither of us had established what it could reliably show from that position.

This was an unofficiated US club match using the USTA Code. The 2026 Friend at Court assigns calls to players on their own side and requires giving opponents the benefit of doubt. I don't want a process argument to become a reason to maintain a call I no longer believe. I also don't want an unagreed display to acquire automatic authority.

We're asking the organiser how to handle the dispute and what applies next time. What would you want clarified about recording, evidence and decisions? I'd like a consistent procedure rather than a separate negotiation over every close ball, without claiming from this description that the app is either accurate or useless.

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep your responsibility for an honest call separate from the app's status. If you have doubt about the ball, don't use the lack of an agreed review system to manufacture certainty. Follow the match's applicable call and dispute procedures.

Ask the organiser who decides a disputed call and whether any review system is part of this competition's arrangements. Your private agreement shouldn't be assumed to replace the rules governing a recorded match.

Clarify recording arrangements as well: who agrees to being recorded, how the equipment is used and what happens to the footage. Don't let solving one point silently establish a new routine for every future session.

What if the club adopts an appropriate review system with a clear procedure? Technology could be useful; the problem doesn't have to be that players should always ignore it.

Agreed. A system adopted for the competition and understood by participants is a different arrangement from one player producing an unagreed verdict mid-match. Ask what procedure the organiser supports and apply it consistently, rather than treat the word “app” as proof for or against the result.

Join the discussion

More in Sports