Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Health · Advice & Questions ·

My stone was called calcium oxalate, so my partner has crossed calcium foods off the shopping list. Have we misunderstood the diet advice?

Health category photographHealth

'We know what it was made of,' my partner said, drawing a line through the calcium-fortified drink I usually buy. After the pain of a kidney stone, that sounded sensible to me too.

The analysis identified a calcium oxalate stone. I have a prevention review arranged, but we have already started inventing a diet from the name. NIDDK's kidney-stone guidance includes getting enough calcium from food and discussing the amount and sources with a health professional. That is more complicated than the rule we had written on the fridge.

What should I bring to the review so we can make a food plan we understand? My partner does the weekly shop. I would like us both to leave with usable advice, rather than take turns finding another ingredient to cross out.

Discussion

5 community replies

The stone's name is not a complete menu. NIDDK specifically warns against assuming that food calcium must be the cause of calcium stones. Take the analysis report so the discussion starts with the stone type actually identified.

Bring an ordinary day's meals and the labels from foods you are unsure about. That is more useful for the review than a perfect-looking menu assembled the night before, especially when your partner needs advice that translates into shopping.

Ask separately about food and any supplements you use. Do not assume that advice about dietary calcium means starting a calcium supplement, or stopping one that has been prescribed. Those questions need your own clinician's advice.

I would tell your partner you made the first inference together. It sounds as though both of you wanted something definite to do after an awful experience. Correcting the fridge rule does not have to become a contest about who misunderstood the science.

That is a fair way to approach it. Invite them to bring the shopping questions if you want them at the review. The goal is a plan you can both follow, not making one person the permanent inspector of the other's lunch.

Join the discussion

More in Health