Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

My sister sold my sofa and wants a third of the price. How do we settle the fee we never named?

Money category photographMoney

My sister offered to sell my old sofa if she could 'keep a bit for the trouble.' I said yes without asking what that meant. She photographed it, answered messages and arranged collection.

Using illustrative amounts, the buyer paid $240. My sister wants $80; I'd pictured something closer to $20 or $30. She still has the payment and says the messages took more time than I realise. I haven't claimed she did nothing, but we're now discussing the price of work that's already finished.

How would you resolve this sale without pretending either person's private expectation was the agreement, and what would you set before accepting her help again?

Discussion

5 community replies

'A bit' left a big gap between your expectations. It would help to acknowledge your part in leaving it vague before challenging the $80. That doesn't require agreeing that her interpretation was the only possible one.

Ask her to explain the work and expenses behind the amount, then explain the amount you pictured. Have that conversation as an attempt to reach a figure now, rather than trying to discover a precise fee neither of you actually stated.

For future sales, choose the amount or percentage before the listing goes up and say how any expenses are handled. You might also decide you'd prefer to do the messages yourself if her price makes the help less useful to you.

She found the buyer and handled all the hassle. You're getting money for a sofa you wanted gone, so keeping a third seems a fair reward for making the sale happen.

Her work has value, but so did the sofa she was selling for you. The fact that the sale was helpful doesn't settle the proportion. You both need to negotiate the unfinished fee question without treating either the asset or the labour as worth nothing.

Join the discussion

More in Money