Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

My RPG character became comic relief, but I want one scene to be taken seriously

Gaming category photographGaming

My character has spent most of our campaign making grand speeches that go wrong. I enjoy the joke and helped establish it. Last session I tried to explain why the character was frightened of returning home, and the others kept supplying punchlines before I could finish.

I hadn't signalled that I wanted a change of tone. To them it may have sounded like another setup. I don't want to ban the humour that made the character fun, but I'd like the fear underneath it to have a little room too.

How would you prepare the table for that kind of scene without asking everyone to become a different group for the evening?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the GM and players beforehand that you would like this particular scene to have a more serious tone. A signal before the scene gives them a chance to respond differently from the pattern you've all enjoyed.

You helped build the comic expectation, so acknowledging it may make the request easier to understand. That doesn't mean the character must remain a joke in every situation forever.

Leave room for the other players to say what they enjoy about the current tone. You're asking to make space for one part of the character, not claiming that their earlier laughter was necessarily cruel.

Give the scene a clear scope: a conversation about returning home, for example, rather than a demand that every future mishap become solemn. The group can discuss whether that fits the campaign.

That can preserve both sides of the character. Once the serious moment has had room to land, humour can return without making the original admission merely another setup for a punchline.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming