Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

My prepared book-club questions are making the evening feel like school

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I brought a page of questions to book club because I wanted us to get beyond saying whether we liked the novel. When I asked why a character burned a letter, nobody answered straight away. I filled the silence with my own reading, then moved to my next question.

A friend told me afterwards that it felt like a quiz where I already knew the answers. I hadn't meant it that way, but I can see how quickly I took over. I still like preparing and want a thoughtful conversation about the book.

What should I change about how I use the questions, rather than deciding that preparation itself is the problem?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the group you're offering possible starting points, not looking for a particular answer. Then give people time to choose where they want the conversation to go.

The silence didn't necessarily mean the question had failed. You can wait, or ask whether someone wants to start with a different scene, before supplying your own interpretation.

Bring fewer questions into the room at once. Following an interesting answer may produce the discussion you wanted more effectively than getting through the page.

Ask your friend which part felt most like a quiz: the wording, your quick answer, or moving on before anyone could respond. Their specific example could help you change the habit without guessing.

And hear that as information about the format, not an instruction to stop caring about the book. You can keep the preparation while making the conversation less dependent on your sequence.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment