Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

My pottery teacher straightened the uneven vase I was trying to make

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

In a beginner pottery class, I was making a vase with one side deliberately lower than the other. I wanted it to look a little lopsided. The teacher came over, said, "Let's rescue that," and straightened the rim before I could explain.

I said I had wanted it uneven. She looked surprised and told me I needed to learn the neat version before breaking the rules. I understand that I've paid for instruction, and I'm willing to practise techniques. But this was the piece we had been told we could design ourselves.

Next week I want to ask her to explain a correction before changing my work. I'm worried she'll hear that as me refusing to be taught. The vase is tidier now, and much less like the one I was enjoying making.

Discussion

5 community replies

"I'm happy to learn the technique. On the design piece, could you talk me through a proposed change before doing it?" That makes the distinction you care about clear: you want instruction and a chance to understand or choose the alteration.

Her surprise suggests you were working from different ideas about the shape. Tell her what you intended before the next demonstration begins. That won't undo this rim, but it gives both of you more information than waiting to see whether she reaches for the piece again.

Was she teaching a specific technique that required a level rim, or responding to what looked like an accident? You can ask without conceding that every uneven feature needs rescuing. The answer would help you understand what freedom the design exercise actually includes.

The word "rescue" would sting if you were pleased with the work. You can mention that briefly, while keeping the main request on what happens next. Otherwise the whole conversation may turn into whether that one word was meant kindly.

Exactly. "I know you meant to help, but I was enjoying that shape" explains the mismatch. Then leave room for her to describe what she was trying to teach. Neither of you needs to prove that the current vase is objectively better.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment