Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

My players negotiated past the battle I'd prepared. How do I stop trying to force it back in?

Gaming category photographGaming

The party offered to repair the damaged bridge in exchange for safe passage. I let the guards accept. Then I looked at the battle map I'd spent an evening preparing and nearly introduced another patrol so we'd still have the fight.

We ended the session before that happened. The players were pleased with their bargain, and I would have been too if I hadn't prepared the encounter. How do I handle the disappointment of unused GM work without quietly undoing their decision? I'd also like a way to prepare that doesn't make every skipped scene feel like an evening wasted.

Discussion

5 community replies

Let the bargain stand. You already gave the guards a reason to accept it; inventing a substitute fight solely to use the map could make that successful decision feel empty.

The map and encounter notes can remain material you might adapt later. You don't need to decide immediately where they must appear, or promise yourself that every detail will eventually get used.

Preparing the guards may have helped you make the negotiation work, even though the battle didn't happen. Useful preparation isn't always visible as the exact scene you expected to run.

Would preparing motives and likely reactions, alongside a smaller amount of combat detail, suit the way this party plays? You could try it for one session rather than redesign your whole method.

That experiment could show which preparation you actually use. Keep enough detail to feel comfortable running the game, but give yourself permission to leave a branch unexplored when the players choose another one.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming