Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

My overseas holding rose in its own currency. Why could it be worth less in dollars?

Money category photographMoney

I was comparing an overseas holding with a US-dollar spending goal using this made-up example. It starts at 1,000 foreign units when each unit equals $1.50: $1,500. It ends at 1,100 units when each equals $1.30: $1,430.

The holding rose by 10% in its local currency, yet the dollar comparison fell by $70, before costs or taxes. These aren't live prices or exchange-rate forecasts.

Investor.gov explains currency risk in international investing. The investment's local return and its value in my spending currency aren't the same calculation.

What would you check on the account and fund documents before comparing performance, rather than assume the two displays contradict each other?

Discussion

5 community replies

Write the investment value, currency and conversion rate at each comparison date together. In your example, 1,100 times $1.30 is $1,430 even though the foreign-unit amount increased.

Ask what currency each performance figure uses and whether it includes conversion costs, distributions or other transactions. Compare figures that cover the same period and assumptions.

Check what currency exposure the actual holding creates and how that fits the goal you intend to fund. The currency displayed by the account doesn't answer every question about the underlying investment.

Could you simply wait for the exchange rate to return to $1.50 and avoid the problem?

There's no established promise that either the rate or the investment value will return to your preferred level on your spending date. Understand the exposure and timeframe rather than build the plan around that reversal.

Join the discussion

More in Money