Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My manager vents about the people I manage, then expects it in their reviews

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

At the end of our check-in, my manager called one person on my team lazy and another impossible to work with. When I asked for examples, he said he was just letting off steam and asked me to keep it between us.

Later he asked whether those concerns would appear in their reviews. I have some ordinary feedback to give both people, but not evidence for those labels.

I don't want to ignore useful information from my manager. I also can't turn a private vent into a judgment my team has no meaningful chance to understand or respond to. How do I ask him to distinguish a concern I should investigate from frustration he isn't asking me to act on?

Discussion

5 community replies

The change from “just venting” to “put it in the review” is the point to clarify. Ask what behaviour he is raising, when it happened and what he expects you to do. Broad labels are not usable instructions for managing someone.

Keep your own review grounded in work you have observed and information you can assess. If a new concern needs looking into, do that separately rather than inserting your manager's conclusion because it arrived through a senior voice.

You can also set a limit on the kind of conversation you can hold: “When it's about my team, I need to know whether you're giving me actionable feedback. Otherwise I end up holding a view I can't use fairly.” That is about your management role, not policing his emotions.

A manager may sometimes have context the team lead doesn't, and not every concern comes with a neat incident log.

Ask for enough context to understand and evaluate it, including what can appropriately be shared or investigated. You don't need to demand a perfect file before listening. You do need more than an insult before adopting it as an assessment of someone's work.

Join the discussion

Useful guidance

Describe one observable problem, explain its effect on the work and ask for a specific next step. Choose a suitable time and keep a factual record. Consider formal channels sooner when the issue involves safety, serious misconduct or a power imbalance.

How to prepare for a difficult conversation at work →

More in Career / Work