Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My manager says the project went well, but I still don’t know what I should repeat

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

At our project review my manager said, “Great work, keep doing what you’re doing.” I was pleased. I had also hoped to understand which choices helped: I had changed the order of the work, cut a section from the launch plan and brought a colleague into client conversations earlier.

All three felt uncertain at the time. Now that the project is finished, the praise seems to cover everything, including decisions that may have made no difference. When I asked for more detail, my manager said there were no problems to discuss.

I don’t want to turn a positive review into a demand for another round of compliments. How can I ask for useful feedback on a success, especially when the manager thinks the absence of criticism should be enough?

Discussion

5 community replies

Bring one decision rather than asking for “more feedback” in general: “Would you want me to involve that colleague at the same stage next time, or earlier?” It gives the manager something to evaluate. You are asking for guidance on the next project, not a more elaborate version of “well done”.

Look at the decision to cut the launch section. Ask what the manager thought you gave up and whether that trade-off was sensible. A useful answer may include something to restore next time even though the overall project went well. Success does not require a verdict that every choice was ideal.

The manager may not have seen enough detail to explain the result. If so, ask which part they did observe and accept a bounded answer. It is better to learn that the client updates were clear than to coax a confident story about how every internal decision caused the good outcome.

A colleague who received the work may be able to answer a more practical question: “What in my handover made your part easier, and what did you still have to chase?” That could provide the detail missing from the manager’s review.

Keep that question about the colleague’s own experience of the work. They may value a different part from the manager, and that is useful information rather than a contradiction to resolve. You can bring the two views together when deciding what to repeat, without asking either person to explain the whole project’s success.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work