Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My manager says a near miss needs no report because nobody was hurt. What should I ask for?

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

A heavy box fell from a warehouse shelf beside the walkway just after someone passed. Nobody was hit. The supervisor closed that section, but when I asked about recording what happened, my manager said, “There’s no injury, so there’s nothing to report.”

I’m an employee in England, not the person responsible for safety reporting. I don’t know whether this particular event meets a statutory reporting category. HSE’s guidance describes specified dangerous occurrences that can require reporting without an injury; that is different from saying every near miss must go to HSE.

I want the event recorded internally and someone appropriate to assess it, without announcing a legal conclusion I can’t support. How would you follow up when the initial answer has already treated “nobody hurt” as the end of the conversation?

Discussion

5 community replies

The useful request is narrower than “you must report this to HSE”: “Who will record the incident, review what happened and decide whether it is reportable?” HSE lists particular dangerous occurrences. No injury does not settle that assessment, but the description here does not establish a listed category either.

Write down what you actually saw, where you were and what happened afterwards. Keep an estimate clearly labelled as an estimate. You can make a useful account without guessing the box’s weight, explaining why the shelf failed or assigning blame to the person who last used it.

The manager may have meant there is no injury form to complete, rather than that nobody will investigate. Before treating this as a cover-up, ask whether a separate near-miss record exists and who owns it. The answer could expose a missing process or simply a misunderstanding.

That is a fair clarification to make. Try: “Understood that nobody was injured. Where does this incident go for review, and who will let us know what happens next?” If the answer is still that no record or assessment is needed, you then have a specific concern to take further. Keep any immediate safety concern in the existing safety process while the reporting question is resolved.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work