Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My manager asked us to name a colleague the team could “do without.” Is that useful restructuring input?

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

The request was marked confidential: “If we had to lose one person, who could the team do without?”

I’m an employee in a Sheffield office. We’ve heard that costs are being reviewed, but there has been no clear explanation of a proposed redundancy process. My manager says this is only informal input and wants a name by tomorrow.

I can describe work that is duplicated and tasks that need more cover. I don’t have a complete picture of each colleague’s responsibilities, and I don’t want a guess or a personal preference turned into evidence about somebody’s job.

I’m also anxious that refusing to answer will look as though I’m avoiding a difficult business question.

How would you respond? What would you ask about the purpose and use of the answers before supplying anything, and what kind of useful information could you offer instead of a name?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what decision the answers will inform, who will see them and whether this is part of an actual redundancy proposal. “Informal input” doesn’t explain how a named response may be used. You can offer evidence about tasks and capacity while seeking that clarification.

If this is redundancy selection, Acas guidance for employers calls for criteria that are as objective and measurable as possible and applied consistently within the relevant pool. That does not let us determine the legal status of this request from one message. Ask for the organisation’s process and seek appropriate Acas or representative advice if needed. Acas guidance.

Your view of another person’s workload may be incomplete. Keep any information you provide tied to work you actually know: a duplicated step, a gap in cover or a responsibility with no clear owner. Avoid filling the gap with assumptions about who seems busiest or whose private circumstances might make losing a job easier.

You could say, “I can identify overlaps in the process, but I can’t responsibly rank colleagues from the part of their work I see. Could we review the functions and evidence being used?” That engages with the business question without inventing a personal assessment you don’t have.

That is a concrete alternative, not merely a refusal to think about costs. If the manager still insists on a name, ask for clarification through the appropriate internal or representative route before treating a guess as your considered evidence. Don’t choose a supposedly safe person just to complete the request; that could give your answer a meaning you don’t intend.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work