Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Health · Advice & Questions ·

My gym coach wants me to replace my PKU protein substitute with a plant-based shake. How do I keep the training goal and question the nutrition advice?

Health category photographHealth

I have phenylketonuria and a nutrition plan from my metabolic team. When I mentioned the protein substitute I use, my gym coach suggested replacing it with the plant-based shake sold at the gym. They thought it would simplify things and suit the strength training I want to do. I have not changed my prescribed plan, but I do want advice that takes the new activity seriously.

The government's PKU explanation describes the problem breaking down phenylalanine. The adult dietetic consensus from UK metabolic specialists discusses individual protein-substitute requirements and considering physical activity.

What should I take to my metabolic dietitian about the training and the suggested product? How do I tell the coach that I want their help with exercise without treating a gym shake as interchangeable with my PKU nutrition?

Discussion

5 community replies

'Plant-based' does not establish whether a product fits your phenylalanine allowance or replaces a prescribed protein substitute. Take the complete product information to your metabolic dietitian. Do not make that substitution on the basis of the coach's general nutrition advice or a front-of-pack description.

Describe the actual training: what you do, how often, how long sessions last and what you hope to achieve. The adult PKU consensus says physical activity should be considered when assessing protein requirements. That supports asking for a plan fitted to the activity, not calculating a new dose from a forum.

Tell the dietitian about the practical issue the coach noticed, such as carrying the substitute, timing it around sessions or tolerating it. There may be a useful discussion underneath the unsuitable shortcut. Ask what changes, if any, your own treatment and monitoring require.

You could tell the coach: 'Please help me work on the training. Changes to my PKU nutrition need to go through my metabolic team.' Ask them not to include the shake automatically in a package you pay for while the product is being reviewed.

Getting the package contents clear would also avoid buying a subscription out of politeness. Once you have advice from your dietitian, share only the exercise-relevant arrangements you want the coach to know. You do not have to hand over all your metabolic results to keep receiving coaching.

Join the discussion

More in Health