Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

My golf opponent conceded a putt, then changed his mind after seeing the distance. Can he take it back?

Sports category photographSports

In a club match-play game, my ball stopped short of the hole. My opponent looked over and said, "That's conceded, pick it up." I lifted it. When we walked closer, he said he hadn't realised how far away it was and wanted me to put it back and putt.

I hadn't asked for a concession. I thought he'd made one, and R&A Rule 3.2b says a clearly communicated concession is final and cannot be withdrawn. He says insisting on it would be taking advantage of an honest mistake.

How should I handle that conversation during a match? I want the rule applied properly, but I don't want the remaining holes to become a dispute about whether I'm sporting enough.

Discussion

5 community replies

In match play, a clear concession of the next stroke can't be withdrawn simply because the opponent later dislikes the distance. On the words you've described, point calmly to Rule 3.2b. This isn't an arrangement to carry over into stroke play, where you can't use an opponent's concession to finish a hole.

If you disagree about what was communicated, ask the referee or Committee for a ruling promptly through the event's procedure. Give the exact words, when the ball was lifted and what each player understood. An online account can't determine disputed facts for your match.

You can acknowledge the awkwardness without agreeing that following the rule is bad manners: "I understand you saw the distance differently when you came over. I lifted it because you said the stroke was conceded. Let's get the ruling clarified."

Does the rule allow for someone reasonably misunderstanding a remark? I wouldn't want every casual "that's fine" treated as a concession.

It does address reasonable misunderstanding, including replacing a ball lifted because of it. That's different from withdrawing a concession that was clearly made. If your opponent disputes the meaning of the words, tell the official that; don't decide it solely from how confident either player sounds.

Join the discussion

More in Sports