Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

My gaming friend wants a crafting fee after I supplied the materials. What should we agree before the next item?

Gaming category photographGaming

I handed over the ore and asked whether he could make the sword. After crafting it, my friend asked for a fee in the game's coins. I hadn't known there would be one.

He spent time developing the crafting skill and says materials aren't the whole contribution. I agree. I had also gathered supplies for him during earlier sessions without asking for anything back, so I thought we were helping each other informally.

We never discussed a price or a continuing exchange. My earlier gifts don't prove that he accepted a permanent job crafting for free. His effort also doesn't tell me what fee I agreed to before this sword was made.

How would you settle this item and organize future requests? I'd like to recognize what he contributes without turning every favor into a ledger, or discover the terms only when the work is already complete.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him you didn't know there would be a fee and ask how he understood the request. Keep that separate from whether his crafting effort has value. The disagreement is partly about terms that weren't discussed.

Don't convert all your earlier supply gifts into an invoice unless that was the arrangement at the time. You can explain why they shaped your expectation without claiming they establish a balance he already owes.

Ask what the fee covers and decide whether a one-time agreed exchange would settle this sword. Both of you can acknowledge the misunderstanding without pretending there was a clear quote before the work began.

For future items, agree on materials, any coin fee and what each person is undertaking before crafting starts. A short answer can be enough. The point is to let both players choose the exchange while there is still a choice to make.

Keep casual gifts clearly separate when you want them to remain gifts. Otherwise even a friendly bag of ore can become an unspoken promise of later labor. You can be generous without requiring every favor to carry the same terms.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming