My friend says the film's music made my tears too easy
EntertainmentI cried during the final scene of a film. Afterwards a friend said the scene hadn't earned that reaction: “Take away the strings and you'd feel nothing.”
I could hear the music, and I still found the scene moving. My friend wanted to talk about whether the score was doing work the story hadn't done. I think that's an interesting question. But when I said I loved the ending, they treated my tears as evidence that I'd been fooled rather than as part of my response.
How do I discuss whether the scene was heavy-handed without having to prove that my feelings survived an imaginary version of the film with its music removed?