Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

My friend says the film's music made my tears too easy

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I cried during the final scene of a film. Afterwards a friend said the scene hadn't earned that reaction: “Take away the strings and you'd feel nothing.”

I could hear the music, and I still found the scene moving. My friend wanted to talk about whether the score was doing work the story hadn't done. I think that's an interesting question. But when I said I loved the ending, they treated my tears as evidence that I'd been fooled rather than as part of my response.

How do I discuss whether the scene was heavy-handed without having to prove that my feelings survived an imaginary version of the film with its music removed?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can discuss the film that was actually shown. The music is part of that version, so noticing its effect doesn't require you to withdraw your response.

Your friend is asking a useful craft question about how the scene works. Try separating that from the judgement that your reaction was gullible; you can engage with the first and object to the second.

Ask what felt unearned to them in the story. That gives you something concrete to compare with what moved you, instead of trying to demonstrate how you would feel under different conditions.

You might agree that the score was emphatic and still like the scene. A conversation doesn't need to end with one shared verdict on whether the tears were justified.

Nor do you need to agree about the score to keep talking. You can explain what you noticed and liked, while leaving your friend room to find the same choices excessive.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment