Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

My friend says he can't trust me after I bluffed in our deduction game. How do I talk about it?

Gaming category photographGaming

"You looked straight at me and said you weren't the saboteur," my friend said after the reveal. I was the saboteur. Concealing that role was the task on my card.

It was his first game with us. We explained the turns and told him people could bluff, but I don't think we made clear how directly someone might deny their role. He joined because he likes solving puzzles, and the reveal felt different from the activity he expected.

I laughed when he said he'd believed me. I meant it as delight that the bluff had worked; he heard me enjoying having made him look foolish. That is the part I regret.

How do I explain the game without using its rules to dismiss his reaction? I'd happily choose something without this kind of deception next time. I also don't want the discussion to become a claim that my secret role describes how I treat him outside the game.

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologize for laughing at the moment he felt exposed. That is a concrete response you can change. You don't need to apologize for completing the role you were given in order to recognize that your reaction landed badly.

Ask what he thought bluffing would involve. The group may have explained the word while skipping the kind of direct denial he was about to encounter. That is useful information for introducing this game to anyone new.

Keep the explanation narrow: you denied the role because the game asked you to conceal it. Avoid telling him that being upset proves he can't take a joke. His first experience can have been unpleasant even if the move was allowed.

Offer a different game next time without asking him to retry this one as proof that the friendship is repaired. He might enjoy the group more when trust isn't the material the evening plays with.

And let that offer be ordinary. Announcing that everyone must avoid lying games because he was upset could make the replacement another embarrassing event. Ask what he'd enjoy and invite the group to something suitable.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming