Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

My friend says feedback isn't useful unless I rewrite the confusing part

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I read a friend's short story and said I'd lost track of who was speaking in one exchange. They asked me to supply better dialogue. When I said I could point out where I became confused but didn't have replacement lines, they replied that criticism without a solution wasn't useful.

I had agreed to give a reader's response. I don't want to drop a vague “this doesn't work” on them and leave, but I also don't want to rewrite their characters in my voice just to make my observation acceptable.

How can I make the feedback specific enough to use while being honest about the kind of help I can offer?

Discussion

5 community replies

Point to the first line where you lost track and say who you thought was speaking at that point. That gives your friend more usable information than a general verdict, without inventing replacement dialogue.

They may be asking for something actionable because they don't know what caused the confusion. Ask whether explaining your reading of the exchange would help them investigate it.

If you have a possible fix, offer it as one option. You don't need to present a rewrite as the only way to demonstrate that the reading problem occurred.

Agree on the feedback you're offering before the next draft: observations and questions, with suggestions when you actually have them. Your friend can then decide whether that is the kind of reader they need.

And you can accept that they may want a different kind of help without withdrawing what you observed. A clear account of your reading doesn't become dishonest or worthless because you aren't the person who will solve the scene.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment