My friend says feedback isn't useful unless I rewrite the confusing part
EntertainmentI read a friend's short story and said I'd lost track of who was speaking in one exchange. They asked me to supply better dialogue. When I said I could point out where I became confused but didn't have replacement lines, they replied that criticism without a solution wasn't useful.
I had agreed to give a reader's response. I don't want to drop a vague “this doesn't work” on them and leave, but I also don't want to rewrite their characters in my voice just to make my observation acceptable.
How can I make the feedback specific enough to use while being honest about the kind of help I can offer?