Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

My friend praises my singing for sounding like the original, but I want to make different choices

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

I've been rehearsing a cover for an informal music evening. At first I copied the recording closely because that helped me decide what to do with each phrase. A friend listened and said the best part was that I sounded just like the original singer.

I was pleased, then oddly stuck. I now want to try a quieter opening and a less dramatic ending. My friend says those changes remove the things people recognise and that I should keep the version I've worked hard to learn.

I'm not performing as a tribute act or advertising an exact recreation. I also don't want to change things randomly just to claim the song is “my own.” I like parts of the original delivery and parts of my newer attempt.

How do I choose what to keep without making resemblance either the entire goal or something I have to avoid?

Discussion

5 community replies

What did you enjoy singing in each version? Start there before deciding how much similarity is acceptable. You have described specific choices you want to try, rather than change for its own sake.

Your friend's compliment tells you what they enjoyed. It doesn't have to become the brief for your performance, especially when you haven't promised a recreation.

You can keep the phrasing you like from the version you learned. Making a deliberate choice doesn't require every detail to be different from the recording.

Try the two endings for someone without introducing one as the faithful version and the other as your personal version. Ask what each ending does for the song as they hear it.

The listener's explanation may be more useful than a vote for a winner. You still get to choose, but you'll have a response to the actual endings rather than to the labels you gave them.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment