Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Entertainment · Advice & Questions ·

My friend is hurt that I lied convincingly in a bluffing game

Entertainment category photographEntertainment

We played a hidden-role game where the rules explicitly allow you to lie about your role. I was the saboteur and convinced my friend I was helping them. At the reveal I laughed and said, “You're so easy to fool.”

They were quiet afterwards and later said it was unsettling how convincing I'd been. I replied that lying was the point of the game. They said the game was one thing, but they didn't like feeling that I'd enjoyed making them look foolish.

I still think my move was fair. I also hear how smug my comment sounds now that we're outside the game. I don't want to apologise as if playing my assigned role was a betrayal, but “those are the rules” clearly hasn't addressed what upset them.

What should I take responsibility for, and is there a way to discuss whether we should play this kind of game together again?

Discussion

5 community replies

The personal remark is the clearest thing to apologise for. You can say you enjoyed landing the move and then made it into a comment about their judgement, which wasn't fair to them.

Your friend's second message draws the distinction you're trying to make: the bluff was part of play, the feeling of being mocked wasn't. Respond to that clarification instead of repeating the rules.

A fair move can still belong to a game someone doesn't enjoy. You can keep your view of the move while accepting that this might not be a good choice for another evening together.

Ask about future games after the apology has had some room. Otherwise “shall we stop playing this?” could sound like a consequence for saying your comment hurt.

Timing helps there. First own the jab without conditions. Later, offer other games as a way to have fun together, with no need for your friend to prove they're a good sport by choosing bluffing again.

Join the discussion

More in Entertainment