Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

My friend asked for honest feedback on dinner. How candid should I be while everyone is still eating?

Food category photographFood

My friend served a dish she'd been practising and asked, 'Tell me honestly what you'd change.' I liked parts of it but found the sauce much sweeter than I prefer. Everyone else was still taking their first bites.

I said it was lovely, then felt I'd dodged the question. I also didn't want my answer to start a group critique of a meal she'd spent the afternoon making. She asked again afterwards whether I'd meant it.

How would you give a useful answer without either inventing praise or treating an invitation to comment as permission to take the dinner apart? I can describe my own preference; I don't know whether she wanted recipe notes at that moment or just a straightforward reaction.

Discussion

5 community replies

Answer at the scale of the question: 'I liked the texture; the sauce was sweeter than I usually choose.' That is honest and specific without pretending your preference is a defect everyone will share.

Ask, 'Do you want thoughts now, or shall we talk about the recipe later?' She can want useful feedback and still prefer to enjoy the meal before discussing changes.

Don't recruit the table to endorse your view. Asking 'Did everyone else find it too sweet?' turns feedback into a vote.

If she asks for honesty and then dislikes the answer, is it better to refuse food feedback altogether?

You can narrow what you're willing to do: 'I'm happy to say what I enjoyed and what I'd choose differently.' If those conversations keep becoming unpleasant, stop agreeing to critique. But this particular invitation may only need a clearer scope, not a permanent ban.

Join the discussion

More in Food