Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

My friend asked for advice while I watched his board game. Did I need the other players' agreement too?

Gaming category photographGaming

He asked what I would do, so I pointed at a move. His opponent said, "Are we playing against both of you now?"

I wasn't in this game. I had finished something at another table and stopped to watch. It was a casual competitive game among friends, and nobody had discussed spectator advice. I assumed being invited by the player whose turn it was settled the question.

It didn't feel harmless from the other side of the board. My friend wanted help, but the others had joined a game against him. I don't want to make him feel embarrassed for asking or act as if every table must forbid conversation.

How would you handle it now and on the next visit? I'd like to know when watching can include suggestions, and when the help should wait until the game is over.

Discussion

5 community replies

Pause the advice and ask the whole table what kind of game they want. The active player's invitation explained why you spoke, but it didn't establish what the opponents had agreed to play.

Acknowledge the effect without blaming your friend for the request. You both made an assumption. The other players can object to an extra adviser without treating either of you as deliberately dishonest.

Be careful about any hidden information you have seen while watching. Even an ordinary suggestion can be different when the spectator knows more than the player is supposed to know. Don't reveal that information in the discussion.

Offer to discuss the position after the game, or join a future teaching game where everyone understands that advice is part of the activity. That keeps the help available in a form the table can choose.

If they choose a teaching game, ask before stepping into every turn. Permission for some advice isn't necessarily a request for a running solution. You can support learning while leaving people enough room to make their own moves.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming