Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Weddings · Advice & Questions ·

My fiancé wants to wear his first wedding ring on our wedding day. How do we talk about it?

Weddings category photographWeddings

At our ring fitting, my fiancé explained that he plans to wear our new ring on his left hand and keep the ring from his first marriage on his right. His first wife died several years ago. He has worn that ring throughout our relationship, so the plan shouldn't have surprised me, but I had imagined our ceremony differently.

He says the two rings mean different things and keeping one doesn't diminish the other. I believe he means that. I also feel a pang imagining our wedding photographs, and then feel ashamed of having it. I don't want to ask him to remove something important just to produce a tidier image of his life.

How do I tell him what caught me off guard without making the conversation a demand to choose between marriages? We need to understand each other before the day, not have me silently hoping he'll change his mind at the last minute.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with the surprise you describe, rather than a request about his hands: “I know you've always worn it. Seeing our rings together made me realise I had imagined the ceremony differently, and I need to talk about that.” He can hear a feeling more clearly when he isn't being asked to defend his history immediately.

His explanation is also information about what he intends to bring to this marriage. Take it seriously rather than treating the ring as a styling decision he might casually reverse. You can decide what the combination means to you without insisting there is only one correct interpretation.

Try naming what the photograph seems to say to you. Is it fear that your marriage will be compared, worry about relatives' reactions, or a wish for a symbol that belongs to the two of you? Those concerns would lead to different conversations; removing the ring might not answer them.

I wouldn't ask his children or relatives to settle this. That could make a private conversation feel like a vote about his first wife. Talk together first, with enough time to revisit it rather than trying to reach a verdict at the next fitting.

Keeping relatives out also protects you from performing an acceptance you haven't reached. You don't have to announce every feeling to the family. But do tell your fiancé where you actually are, so he isn't mistaking your silence for agreement or discovering the hurt through a comment about the photos.

Join the discussion

More in Weddings