Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

My ETF trade has no commission. Why could buying and selling immediately still lose money?

Money category photographMoney

The broker advertises zero commission, so I assumed a quick trade itself would cost nothing. In a simplified ETF quote, the ask is $10.05 and the bid is $10.00.

Buying 100 shares at that ask costs $1,005. Selling the same number immediately at that unchanged bid returns $1,000, before any other costs. This is an illustration, not an instruction to make those trades.

The SEC's ETF bulletin explains the bid-ask spread as a trading cost.

What would you compare before deciding whether frequent small trades fit the plan? I want to distinguish an absent commission from an assumption that entering and leaving a position has no cost.

Discussion

5 community replies

The example's $5 difference comes from the two quoted prices: 100 times five cents. You haven't assumed a market move, so a zero commission doesn't remove that difference.

Look at the actual quote, available quantities and the fund's published spread information. A snapshot isn't a promise about later execution or a complete estimate for every trade size.

Keep ongoing fund expenses and any other account charges in the wider comparison too. Different costs can be absent or present independently.

Does this mean choosing the ETF with the smallest spread is the whole decision?

No. The investment objective, holdings, risks and other costs still need to fit. The spread is one cost you've identified, not a replacement for evaluating the investment or a guarantee of its future return.

Join the discussion

More in Money