Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

My essential bills don't fit the 50/30/20 budget. Is changing the percentages cheating?

Money category photographMoney

I tried a budget worksheet and got stuck before entering anything fun. My take-home pay is $1,800 a month. The rent, utilities, basic groceries and transport I've entered total $1,300. Half my take-home pay would be $900.

I've checked that the $1,300 isn't hiding meals out or shopping. There may be things I can change over time, but the next rent payment won't become smaller because I put it in another column.

The CFPB's spending-rule worksheet presents the familiar percentages as a guideline and invites people to create a rule suited to their circumstances.

I like having a target. I don't like a sheet that makes me feel defeated before I decide what to do with the remaining $500. How would you keep a useful savings aim without pretending my current needs fit a percentage they don't?

Discussion

5 community replies

The $400 difference between your present needs and the 50% marker is information, not money the worksheet can supply. Keep the actual bills in the budget and make any longer-term cost changes a separate project.

Check what still has to come out of the $500: debt payments, irregular essentials and anything missed in the first pass. Then choose an initial savings amount from what is actually left.

A small rule you can act on might be 'set aside this chosen amount on payday and review it after a month.' You can keep a future percentage target without claiming you've reached it today.

If everyone can change the percentages, how does the rule stop becoming permission to justify whatever they already spend?

By pairing the revised rule with evidence and a review date. Here that means the actual $1,300 list, the remaining obligations and a specific target. Flexibility doesn't require hiding the spending or abandoning a goal; it lets you test a plan against the month you actually have.

Join the discussion

More in Money