Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

My cricket captain wants me to confirm a catch, but I didn't see whether the ball carried. What can I honestly say?

Sports category photographSports

"You were right there. Tell them it was clean," our captain said. A teammate had taken a low catch close to where I was fielding. I saw the ball heading towards his hands, then another player blocked my view of the final moment.

The batter asked whether it had touched the ground. The catcher said no. I have no reason to accuse him of lying, but I can't confirm the part I didn't see. The captain thinks refusing to back him will make it sound as though I doubt our own player.

I said that my view was blocked and left the decision with the umpires. Afterwards the captain told me that wasn't much help to the team.

How should I discuss it before the next match? I'd like to support a teammate without converting trust in him into a claim that I witnessed something myself.

Discussion

5 community replies

You gave the useful information you actually had: you couldn't see the final moment. That doesn't contradict the catcher. Repeating his account as your own observation would make your statement sound stronger while making it less accurate.

A specific explanation may help: "I saw the ball approaching, but the other fielder blocked the contact with the hands." Keep it that precise. Don't fill in the unseen part because the first part looked promising.

Avoid turning the conversation into a character judgment about the catcher. He can describe what he experienced; you can describe your limited view. The umpires can deal with the decision without the team manufacturing agreement between the witnesses.

Would it be reasonable to say, "I believe him, but I didn't see it"? That might reassure the teammate while keeping the observation clear.

You can express personal trust in a private conversation, but in the appeal I'd keep the evidence unambiguous: "My view was blocked." Otherwise a listener may hear only the endorsement. You aren't required to announce distrust in order to decline to corroborate an unseen catch.

Join the discussion

More in Sports