Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

My career mentor has offered me a job. Who do I discuss the decision with now?

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

My mentor has offered me a role in their department. It sounds interesting, and I'm pleased they thought of me.

Usually they're the person I talk to when comparing career options. Now they would be my manager, and their team needs someone to fill this vacancy. I want to ask frank questions about the workload and whether the move fits my goals, but I'm conscious that my decision also affects them.

I don't think they're misleading me. I do think I need a perspective that isn't part of the hiring conversation. How do I make that change without suggesting I no longer trust someone who has been generous with their advice?

Discussion

5 community replies

They can give you valuable information about the job while someone else helps you assess the choice. Tell them you appreciate the offer and want to consider it carefully, including talking it through independently. That doesn't accuse them of giving bad advice.

A history of helpful mentoring doesn't create a debt payable by accepting their vacancy. Keep your gratitude separate from your assessment of the actual work, reporting relationship and move you would be making.

Prepare questions about the role itself, then ask an independent person to help you test what the answers mean for your goals. It may help to write down what you wanted from your next move before this particular offer arrived.

The mentor may be the person who understands those goals best. Their being interested in hiring the candidate doesn't erase years of knowing what matters to them.

True. You don't have to discard that understanding or stop asking them questions. Recognise the additional role they're now in and add another perspective, rather than treating their enthusiasm as either proof the job is right or evidence they have become untrustworthy.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work