Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

My aunt gave me $5,000. Should I set aside a quarter of it for income tax?

Money category photographMoney

My aunt transferred $5,000 as a birthday gift. My brother told me to reserve 25% because 'money coming into your account is income.'

We're both in the US. This is a personal cash gift from a relative, with no work or repayment attached. The 25% is his guess, not a rate anyone calculated.

IRS Publication 17 says gifts are generally excluded from the recipient's income, while income later produced by gifted property can have a different treatment. The IRS gift-tax FAQ also distinguishes the donor's usual gift-tax responsibility from the recipient's position.

I'm happy to check rather than spend first. What details and records would you gather so this is treated as the gift it is, instead of either withholding an arbitrary amount forever or assuming every payment labelled 'gift' has the same tax result?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the transfer record and your aunt's message describing the gift. Those show what happened; there's no need to invent an invoice or describe it as payment for something you didn't do.

The question is the nature and source of the payment, not merely that a bank balance increased. Your brother's guessed percentage doesn't establish a tax obligation.

Keep any later account interest distinct from the original $5,000. The IRS discussion makes that distinction, so 'the gift isn't generally income' shouldn't turn into 'nothing connected with it could ever be taxable.'

Could asking your aunt about paperwork make it sound as though her generous gift created a problem?

You can explain that you're organizing your own records and thanking her for the gift, not asking her to fund a guessed tax bill. If a real reporting question remains, take the actual details to a qualified tax adviser rather than treating a family guess as the answer.

Join the discussion

More in Money