Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Is writing down a birthday less thoughtful than remembering it unaided?

Parenting category photographParenting

My twelve-year-old wrote Grandma's birthday in his planner after forgetting it last year. I said it would mean more if he remembered because he cared, rather than because of a note. He pointed to the family calendar where I keep birthdays and appointments.

I didn't have a good answer. I value the personal thought that goes into a call or card, but I seem to have dismissed a step he took to make sure it happens. My partner thinks planning ahead is exactly what we'd been asking him to do.

How would you correct the message? I don't want family affection to become a test of unaided memory, and I also don't want the date in the planner to be treated as the whole gesture. I'd like to help him turn his reminder into whatever contact he actually wants to make.

Discussion

5 community replies

He took action after something went wrong last year. I'd recognise that before discussing the eventual call or card. The note doesn't need to compete with caring; it can be something he chose to do because the occasion matters to him.

Ask what he'd like to do and whether anything needs preparing before the day. A date and a small plan can work together. Let the gesture be manageable rather than turning his new reminder into a list of everything a thoughtful grandchild should produce.

Your own calendar is a useful correction to acknowledge. You don't have to defend an adult exception. "I use reminders too; I was unfair about yours" answers the comparison he actually made.

Keep the same generous interpretation if he still forgets something despite writing it down. You can deal with a missed call or late card without deciding that one planning mistake reveals how much he loves Grandma.

And a repair can stay ordinary: get in touch, acknowledge that it is late and consider what to change next time. He doesn't have to abandon reminders because they weren't perfect, or prove his affection with a bigger present.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting