Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

Is taking notes fair in a game that's meant to test our memory?

Gaming category photographGaming

Halfway through our memory game, my cousin opened a notebook and wrote down where several cards had appeared. They said everyone had seen the same cards, so they weren't recording secret information. I said remembering those positions was the challenge.

We hadn't agreed about notes before starting. My cousin finds the game frustrating without some way to keep track and thought the notebook made it possible to enjoy the evening. I don't want to turn that into an argument about how good someone's memory ought to be, but I also don't want to compare unaided recall with a written record as though we'd chosen the same challenge.

How could we decide on a version that works for this table, including choosing a different game if our preferences don't fit?

Discussion

5 community replies

Look at what this game's rules say about outside aids, then discuss whether you want to play that version. Publicly seen information can still be something a game asks players to remember.

The notebook may be a request for a more enjoyable way to participate, rather than an attempt to get away with something. You can take that seriously while explaining why it changes the challenge for you.

If you try a version that allows notes, make that available to everyone from the start. Don't require your cousin to justify the preference with a personal explanation.

A cooperative memory attempt might suit the evening better than scoring individual recall. That would be a deliberate variation to agree on, rather than declaring the current comparison unchanged.

That sounds worth offering if the group likes the idea. It also leaves room for someone to prefer a different game entirely; including your cousin doesn't require everyone to enjoy the same memory variant.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming