Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Is ‘it’s obviously fake’ enough when my teenager alters a friend’s face for a joke poster?

Parenting category photographParenting

My seventeen-year-old used an AI image tool to put a friend’s face on a superhero poster and sent it to their group chat. It was fully clothed and meant as a flattering joke. The friend asked him to remove it and stop using his face. My son says nobody could mistake it for a real photograph, so the objection makes no sense.

I initially focused on whether the picture was convincing. The Australian eSafety Commissioner’s guidance on AI-altered school imagery makes clear that non-sexual altered images can also cause harm, and stresses consent and the effect on the person depicted. I do not need to call this poster a crime to take his friend’s request seriously.

I want him to stop sharing it and deal with the objection, but he thinks that means admitting he intended to humiliate someone. How do I distinguish a friendly intention from permission to use someone’s likeness in a new image?

Discussion

5 community replies

The friend does not have to prove that viewers were fooled to dislike the poster. Ask your son to answer the actual request: stop using that face and stop sharing the image. Its realism is a different question.

He can acknowledge the effect without inventing a malicious motive: ‘I meant it as a compliment, but I used your face without asking and you’ve said you don’t want that.’ Leaving out a defensive ‘only a joke’ would help.

Get specific about where he sent it and what he can now do there. Do not promise that removing his own post will remove every copy. Ask him to tell the group the friend wants it taken down, without circulating it again.

Make room for creative work that does not require the friend to surrender this boundary. He could design a fictional hero instead. I would avoid asking him to make a better version of the same friend as the proposed repair.

Agreed. The friend has asked for the use to stop, not requested a redesign. An alternative poster is for the teenager’s future project; it should not become another reason to send the friend an unwanted image or seek approval repeatedly.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting