Is ‘it’s obviously fake’ enough when my teenager alters a friend’s face for a joke poster?
ParentingMy seventeen-year-old used an AI image tool to put a friend’s face on a superhero poster and sent it to their group chat. It was fully clothed and meant as a flattering joke. The friend asked him to remove it and stop using his face. My son says nobody could mistake it for a real photograph, so the objection makes no sense.
I initially focused on whether the picture was convincing. The Australian eSafety Commissioner’s guidance on AI-altered school imagery makes clear that non-sexual altered images can also cause harm, and stresses consent and the effect on the person depicted. I do not need to call this poster a crime to take his friend’s request seriously.
I want him to stop sharing it and deal with the objection, but he thinks that means admitting he intended to humiliate someone. How do I distinguish a friendly intention from permission to use someone’s likeness in a new image?