Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

Is it rude to season my own portion before tasting a dinner someone cooked?

Food category photographFood

I reached for salt and pepper as soon as my friend put my plate down. She asked me to taste it first. I said I was only changing my own food, then realised I'd sounded as though I was defending a decision I hadn't thought about.

Adding them was a habit. I didn't know whether the dish needed anything, and she had seasoned it deliberately. I still think the person eating should be able to adjust their portion.

How would you handle that moment next time? I'd be happy to taste first; I don't want that courtesy to turn into asking permission for every adjustment afterwards.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tasting first seems like a small courtesy you already want to offer. Then adjust your own portion if you prefer it another way. Those don't have to be competing principles.

'That was automatic; I'll try it first' would acknowledge her request without starting a dispute about the plate.

The cook may hear seasoning before tasting as a verdict that their food must need correction. You don't have to agree with that interpretation to explain that this was a habit rather than a considered review.

Would you ask the host to leave salt and pepper on the table so guests can choose without announcing it?

That can make adjustments less conspicuous, but it doesn't answer the first-bite point by itself. The simplest arrangement here is to taste, make your own choice and let everyone carry on eating without debating each turn of the grinder.

Join the discussion

More in Food