Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

Is it reasonable to ask a host to keep their dog separate from my frightened child?

Parenting category photographParenting

When we arrived at my friend's house, her dog rushed over to greet us. My five-year-old stepped behind me and started crying. My friend said he should let the dog sniff his hand so he could see how friendly she is.

I said he did not have to touch her, and we went outside while my friend took the dog away from the doorway. No bite or injury occurred. My friend was hurt that we did not come back in immediately. She says the dog has never bitten anyone and that shutting her away would be unfair in her own home.

We are invited again next weekend. My son wants to see his friend but asks whether the dog will be there. The CDC says any dog can bite and that young children need supervision around dogs, including familiar pets. I am not trying to label this dog dangerous or turn the visit into a treatment for his fear.

Can I ask for an owner-arranged, secure separation that keeps both comfortable, or should I simply suggest meeting elsewhere? I do not want to arrive with a condition my friend has already refused.

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask before the visit and allow a real no: “Can we arrange a visit with the dog securely separate from him? If that does not work for you or the dog, let's meet somewhere else.” You are deciding what visit you can accept, rather than demanding that your friend change her home.

A history of no bites is not a guarantee. The CDC guidance supports supervision even with familiar dogs. It also does not require a frightened child to offer a hand or touch the dog to demonstrate good manners.

Your friend may reasonably care about where her dog can settle comfortably. Let her decide whether a suitable separate area is available instead of prescribing a cupboard, crate or room. If there is no arrangement she can maintain, a different venue is a practical answer.

I would not sell next weekend to your son as a chance to “get over it.” Tell him the actual arrangement once the adults agree it. He can want to see his friend and still decline contact with the dog.

Exactly. If the plan changes on arrival, honour the arrangement you explained rather than asking him to be brave because you are already at the door. You can reschedule or move the visit. Learning about dogs another time, if he wants support with that, need not be the price of seeing this friend.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting