Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Is an AI argument for my preferred layout useful evidence that the group should choose it?

Technology category photographTechnology

I prefer large cards for our resource page; my co-organiser prefers a compact list. I asked an AI assistant to make the case for cards and brought its answer to the meeting as support.

My co-organiser asked, “Did you ask it to compare them, or to defend the one you already wanted?” The prompt was the second kind.

The answer contains ideas worth discussing, but I can see I presented a prepared argument as if it were an independent verdict. How would you use it fairly now? I want us to choose a layout that helps people find resources, rather than settle the disagreement by quoting the more confident paragraph.

Discussion

5 community replies

Show the relevant prompt and describe the answer accurately: it is a case you asked to be made. That doesn't make every point worthless. It does change how the group should interpret the document you presented.

Agree on the page's main jobs before comparing layouts. Finding a known item, browsing unfamiliar resources and reading descriptions may lead to different priorities. Judge the suggestions against those tasks instead of letting the output supply the decision criteria unnoticed.

You could ask for a case for the list as well, but don't treat equal-length arguments as proof that the options are equally good. Use them to identify questions you still need to answer, not to manufacture a tie or another verdict.

Try the actual resource-finding task with both proposed layouts and examine where someone gets stuck. A concrete comparison would give the discussion something beyond either person's preferred description of the design.

Include a task that might favour the other layout, not only the example that makes your cards look best. Otherwise the exercise could repeat the original prompt's framing in a more convincing form. Explain what the comparison did and didn't establish.

Join the discussion

More in Technology