Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Travel · Advice & Questions ·

Is a phone identification result enough to cook wild mushrooms at our holiday cottage?

Travel category photographTravel

Rosa recognises the name suggested by her phone and says it would make a good omelette. Her friend, Will, asks whether either of them actually knows how to identify the mushrooms in the cottage garden.

They are holidaying in Victoria, Australia. Neither has mushroom-identification expertise. They have not picked, cooked or eaten the mushrooms; Rosa has only compared photographs through an app.

Victoria's current health advisory says not to pick and eat wild mushrooms unless you are an expert. It warns that poisonous varieties can resemble edible ones and that cooking does not neutralise the poison in the dangerous mushrooms it describes. A familiar-looking name on a phone does not establish the expertise the advisory calls for.

How can they keep the discovery interesting without putting it in dinner? Will wants them to choose food from a reputable retailer and leave the identification question separate from the meal.

Discussion

5 community replies

Do not cook the garden mushrooms on this basis. Follow the Victorian health advice: people without the relevant expertise should not pick and eat wild mushrooms.

Frying them thoroughly would not resolve the identification problem. The advisory specifically warns that cooking, peeling or drying certain poisonous mushrooms does not remove their poison.

They could keep the photographs for learning and make an omelette from ingredients bought from a reputable source. Rosa does not need to lose her interest in the find when dinner is ruled out.

That would separate curiosity from a decision they are not equipped to make. They can enjoy finding out more later without treating this evening's shared meal as the test of whether the phone suggestion was right.

Join the discussion

More in Travel