Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Technology · Advice & Questions ·

Is a Mute button enough reason to start our exhibition page's music automatically?

Technology category photographTechnology

The artist wants the exhibition page's soundscape to begin before visitors scroll. I suggested a prominent Play control instead. The designer offered to keep autoplay and put Mute near the bottom of the page.

W3C explains that automatic audio can interfere with screen-reader speech, including someone's ability to find the control that stops it. Its guidance encourages user-initiated sound. W3C's audio-control explanation

How would you preserve the invitation to listen without making silence something visitors have to find? The sound is part of the work; I don't think that settles when everyone should hear it.

Discussion

5 community replies

For audio that plays automatically for more than three seconds, the cited criterion calls for a way to pause or stop it, or control its volume independently of the system volume. The existence of a distant button doesn't, by itself, explain whether people can readily operate it.

A visitor may be using speech output to navigate the page. Asking them to listen through the soundscape until they discover Mute makes the control part of the obstacle. W3C specifically discusses that problem.

Give the soundscape a clear place in the presentation: identify it and invite people to start listening. A deliberate Play choice can still treat the audio as important, rather than reducing it to an unnoticed extra.

If the group keeps autoplay in a draft, test how someone reaches and operates its audio control with the keyboard, before relying on the rest of the page. Put the control where the sound starts affecting the experience.

Don't substitute an instruction to mute the whole computer. That could silence the visitor's screen reader too. The control needs to address the page's audio independently, which is a meaningful difference from telling someone where their system volume button is.

Join the discussion

More in Technology