Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

Is a 2% hurricane deductible based on the repair bill or the insured value?

Money category photographMoney

We're comparing home insurance in New York. One quote lists a 2% hurricane deductible, and my partner read that as a small share of whatever damage we claim. I thought the percentage might apply to the home's insured value instead.

Using illustrative figures, suppose the policy's relevant insured value is $200,000 and a covered loss is $10,000. Two percent of those amounts would be $4,000 or $200. That's a big difference in the cash we'd need available.

New York's insurance guidance explains percentage hurricane deductibles and says the declarations page must state the deductible's dollar amount. We haven't confirmed this quote's exact basis or the event that triggers it.

What would you ask the agent to show in writing before deciding whether the premium fits our budget?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask the agent to identify the value the percentage applies to and show the resulting dollar deductible. In your illustration, 2% of $200,000 is $4,000. That calculation is useful only after confirming that $200,000 is the policy's stated basis.

The trigger matters as well as the percentage. Ask which events activate this hurricane deductible and which deductible applies otherwise. A number on a quote doesn't tell you that every storm claim would receive the same treatment.

Compare the actual dollar amount you would need to absorb with the cash you could make available. A lower premium can look quite different once the deductible is written as a dollar figure beside it. Keep coverage differences in that comparison too.

If the damage were only $10,000, would the deductible shrink to 2% of that bill? Otherwise it seems disproportionately large for a smaller claim.

If this policy applies 2% to a $200,000 insured value, the calculated deductible is still $4,000; it isn't recalculated as 2% of a smaller loss. Have the agent confirm that basis and trigger for the exact quote, rather than treating the illustration as its policy terms.

Join the discussion

More in Money