Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Housing · Advice & Questions ·

Is $420 for extra rental cupboards reasonable if we may move in nine months?

Housing category photographHousing

"We're buying cupboards for someone else's flat," my partner said. I moved the cereal boxes off the chopping board and asked where else they could go.

Our rented kitchen has working cupboards, but very little storage. Nothing is broken. The pots fit; the food then ends up on the worktop. The landlord has approved a professional quote of $420 for an extra set of cupboards, provided we pay and leave them in place when we move. We haven't agreed to the work yet.

We expect to decide in about nine months whether to move nearer my partner's job. I want the clear worktop now, even if the landlord keeps the improvement. My partner would rather buy a $110 trolley we could take with us. The trolley fits beside our dining table, but only if we give up one chair or move it whenever we sit down together.

The $420 is money we could otherwise keep for the move. It also buys something we'd use every day instead of waiting for a future kitchen to make cooking less awkward. How do we decide what temporary comfort is worth when neither option quite gives us the room we want?

Discussion

2 community replies

If you stayed nine months, the cupboard cost would work out at about $47 per month of use. That's a way to discuss the scenario's cost, rather than evidence that it's good value. Would both of you willingly spend that amount each month for the clearer worktop, knowing the cupboards stay behind?

Your partner's objection makes sense if the point of buying furniture is keeping the furniture. Your reason is having usable space during the time you live there. Neither preference needs to be disguised as the only financially sensible one. The landlord benefiting later doesn't tell you how much the improvement is worth to you now.

Join the discussion

More in Housing