Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

In our cooperative board game, I know the move I'd choose and keep directing everyone else's turns

Gaming category photographGaming

My friend moved a piece, and I immediately told her to put it somewhere else. She asked whether I wanted to take her whole turn.

Earlier, she'd asked what I would do. I answered with a complete sequence for the next several turns, then kept correcting deviations. I thought we were working toward the shared win. She wanted help understanding her options, followed by a choice she still got to make.

I know this game better than the others. That doesn't mean I want an evening of performing the solution while they move the pieces. I also don't want to respond to the complaint by refusing every question and waiting for the group to lose.

How would you change the way you offer advice? We need to decide how much collective planning we enjoy, especially when someone sees a promising line. I'd like being helpful to leave the others more involved in the game, rather than turn their turns into confirmations of mine.

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologize for continuing to correct the moves after answering her question. She asked for your perspective; she didn't necessarily hand you control of every later decision. That distinction is a useful place to restart.

Ask whether she wants an explanation of options, your recommendation or time to think first. You can answer the request she makes without expanding it into a plan everyone is expected to follow.

Discuss the style of cooperation the group enjoys. Some tables like detailed shared planning; others want more individual ownership of turns. The shared win doesn't by itself settle which experience everyone came for.

Try asking what the active player is considering before offering your line. Respond to the question or trade-off they identify, then leave room for them to choose. You can still contribute information without narrating every move.

Don't use that room as a way to prove they should have followed your plan. If the choice goes badly, discuss it with the same care you'd want for your own. The aim is a game people participate in, rather than a lesson that makes them more dependent on your permission.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming