Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

If I use salted butter in cookies, should I leave out all the recipe's added salt?

Food category photographFood

The cookie recipe specifies unsalted butter and adds salt separately. I only have salted butter, and my partner says that means leaving out the added salt entirely. I haven't mixed the dough.

King Arthur's butter guide explains that unsalted butter gives the baker control over the salt, and offers an approximate adjustment when using salted butter. That isn't the same as saying its salt always equals the whole amount in a recipe.

How would you choose a sensible approach before baking? I can get the specified butter, follow appropriate substitution advice or choose cookies written for what I have. I'd rather make that decision than guess that every packet and recipe balance each other automatically.

Discussion

5 community replies

Don't treat salted as a precise measurement of the recipe's separate salt. The source gives general adjustment advice; the particular butter and formula still matter.

If you want the original formula, use its specified butter. If you substitute, keep track of both the butter change and the salt adjustment rather than remember only one of them.

Check the recipe author's own notes before looking for a universal conversion. A substitution that suits one batch isn't proof of a rule for all cookies.

I'd buy unsalted butter for this first attempt rather than spend the afternoon trying to match the salt.

That is a straightforward choice when learning this formula matters to you. It doesn't mean salted butter can never work; it means you're choosing control over this particular first batch.

Join the discussion

More in Food