Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

If I use my own reward points for a group gift, is it fair to ask for the others' cash shares?

Money category photographMoney

Three of us are choosing a gift. In an illustrative offer, the item costs £90 in cash or 9,000 reward points that I already hold. We had discussed paying £30 each, but haven't bought anything.

I offered to use my points for the whole item and have the others send me their £30 shares. One friend thinks that would mean charging them for a gift that cost me no cash. I see the points as something I'd be giving up for the purchase, but I don't want to invent a cash value everyone has to accept.

How would you agree the contributions before choosing the payment method?

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell them both payment options before asking anyone to transfer money. Present the proposed £30 shares as an arrangement you want them to agree to, not as reimbursement for £90 of cash you would have spent.

The points have a use for you, but that doesn't establish a price your friends already accepted for them. It may help to explain what you'd otherwise use them for without pretending there's one universal point-to-cash value.

You could also keep your points and split the actual cash purchase three ways if everyone still wants the gift. That is a useful comparison, not a punishment for questioning the points proposal.

You'd receive £60 in cash while spending none. I can understand why that looks like making money from organising the gift.

That appearance is why the arrangement needs to be explicit. You would be giving up the points, but the others need to agree that their £60 is a fair contribution under that option. If they don't, choose another arrangement before buying; neither side has to pretend points are worthless or equivalent to a cash receipt.

Join the discussion

More in Money