Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Money · Advice & Questions ·

If I cash an I bond after 18 months, what does the three-month interest penalty mean?

Money category photographMoney

A course place has become available, and the fee is due next month. Part of the money I could use is in a U.S. Series I savings bond I've held for 18 months. We'd planned to leave it there for at least five years, so my partner calls cashing it now 'throwing away the interest.'

TreasuryDirect explains the redemption rule: I bonds can generally be redeemed after 12 months, but redemption before five years forfeits the final three months of interest. Its 18-month example pays the first 15 months' interest.

I don't want to pretend that cost is nothing, but losing three months' interest sounds different from losing everything the bond earned. How would you work out the actual trade-off between using it for the course and leaving the original plan alone?

Discussion

5 community replies

The phrase 'throwing away the interest' is doing a lot of work. The rule you've linked concerns the final three months of interest, not every month's earnings or three months' worth of your original deposit. Start with that distinction before deciding how significant the cost is.

Get the redemption information for this particular bond and check the amount available and the timing before promising the course provider a payment. An account value and a fee deadline aren't yet a completed funding plan.

The five-year plan had a purpose too. Was this money reserved for something you still need, or was five years simply the period you chose to avoid the interest penalty? That would change how I'd frame the conversation about the course.

If waiting until five years avoids the penalty, shouldn't you leave it alone? It feels wasteful to give up interest when there's a way to keep it.

Keeping the interest is a benefit, but the course place has an earlier deadline. Compare the specific amount forgone, other affordable ways to cover the fee and what waiting would mean for the course. Avoiding a penalty doesn't by itself tell you which goal matters more.

Join the discussion

More in Money