Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Food · Advice & Questions ·

If a café gives me a free pastry and asks for an honest review, should I mention the gift?

Food category photographFood

A café in the US offered me a pastry on the house and said they'd appreciate an honest online review if I wanted to write one. I haven't accepted or posted anything. I don't run a review business, so I'd assumed disclosure was only an influencer issue.

The FTC's endorsement guidance specifically discusses free restaurant meals and says readers should be told about them. The fact that a review can be honest doesn't make the gift irrelevant.

Would you pay normally if you want to avoid the connection, or accept only if you're comfortable being clear about it in any review you later choose to give? I don't want a small kindness to turn into an unspoken promise of praise.

Discussion

5 community replies

If you accept and later endorse the café, tell readers about the free food as the FTC guidance explains. Being a casual customer doesn't make that connection invisible to the people reading the review.

Clarify that you aren't promising a review before accepting. If you don't want any part of that arrangement, paying for what you choose is a straightforward option.

Disclosure and honesty do different jobs. Mentioning a gift doesn't make an invented experience or an opinion you don't hold acceptable. Don't post merely to complete a task you never wanted.

Could you accept the hospitality and simply choose not to review anything?

That can be an option if no review has been promised and the offer truly allows it. Clarify the expectation rather than rely on either person's private assumption. If you do decide to post later, the disclosure question still matters.

Join the discussion

More in Food