Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Parenting · Advice & Questions ·

If a birthday present is meant for family use, should we say that before giving it?

Parenting category photographParenting

We gave our twelve-year-old a set of brush pens for her birthday, wrapped with her name on it. Her younger brother now wants to use them for a large poster. There are ordinary pens in the family cupboard, but he likes her new ones.

I told her to share because we'd paid for them. She asked, "Then why did you wrap them for me?" My partner says art materials have always been shared in our house and that a birthday shouldn't create a permanent ban on lending.

I don't think she needs to refuse every request, but we never said we were upgrading the family art box. She is worried that her favourite colours will be used up on other people's projects before she has tried them. We haven't handed the pens over.

What would be fair now? I'd like generosity to remain part of family life without changing what we meant by her present only after someone else wants it.

Discussion

5 community replies

The wrapping and her name already did some of the explaining. If you intended a shared art set, that needed saying when you gave it. "We paid" doesn't answer why she reasonably understood it as her present.

Ask what she would be comfortable lending rather than making the choice all-or-nothing. She might offer some colours for a short project, or she might want to use the set herself first. Either answer gives you more to work with than an argument about whether she is a generous person.

Her brother can be disappointed without being told she has deprived him of something. There are family pens available for his poster. Help him plan with those while you resolve what you actually gave his sister.

A family art cupboard can still be a good idea. It just shouldn't depend on quietly converting one child's wrapped birthday present into the supply everyone is entitled to use. Plan shared purchases as shared purchases.

Agreed, and that doesn't require buying another premium set immediately. You can keep the existing communal pens, explain the distinction and decide later what the household can provide. The first repair is clarity about this gift, not another shopping trip.

Join the discussion

More in Parenting