Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Sports · Advice & Questions ·

I want takebacks in our casual chess games, but my friend wants every move to count. Can both work?

Sports category photographSports

"You saw it as soon as you let go," my friend said, declining my request to take back a move. It was a casual chess game at my kitchen table, with no rating or competition involved.

He enjoys a game where mistakes stand. I am learning and would like occasional chances to correct a move and understand the position. Neither of us had said which sort of evening we thought we were having.

I was sulky for the rest of the game, which wasn't fair to him. Next time I want to agree the format before we start. Is there a sensible way to include some teaching without making him negotiate every mistake, or should I accept that he wants to be an opponent rather than my tutor?

Discussion

5 community replies

The sulking is worth a brief apology on its own. He wasn't obliged to turn a mid-game request into a new agreement. After that, ask whether he would enjoy a learning game on another occasion; don't present it as a correction he owes you for saying no.

Some of the learning could happen after the game if you both want it. That lets the moves stand while leaving room to revisit an interesting position. It still uses his time, so ask rather than assuming post-game teaching is included with every visit.

A game with agreed takebacks is a different activity you can both choose. The problem is the uncertainty: he is planning against a position while you may want to undo it. A simple agreement before starting would be kinder than repeated pleading after a bad move.

He might enjoy being a friend who plays chess and dislike being cast as the resident teacher. That doesn't mean he is unsupportive. You could seek learning help elsewhere and keep these evenings for the format you both actually enjoy.

That's a fair possibility. Ask once, and believe the answer if he prefers ordinary games. You can still learn from playing him without making him responsible for your progress, while finding a separate setting where teaching and corrections are explicitly part of the session.

Join the discussion

More in Sports