Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Gaming · Advice & Questions ·

I've already run this RPG adventure. How can I join it as a player without taking over?

Gaming category photographGaming

A friend invited me into an RPG campaign using an adventure I ran for another group. I recognised the opening description and told the GM privately that I knew the book. They are still happy for me to play, but we haven't discussed what that means at the table.

I remember a hidden entrance and the identity of someone the party is meant to distrust eventually. Keeping quiet about those facts seems straightforward until the group asks my character to choose where we go. I don't want to steer everyone to the right answer, or act so deliberately wrong that I'm still controlling their experience.

What agreement would let me participate honestly while leaving the other players room to discover the adventure?

Discussion

5 community replies

Agree with the GM how to handle moments when your remembered information becomes relevant. Saying out of character that you need someone else to lead this choice can be cleaner than inventing a strange decision to prove you aren't using the book.

Your character can respond to what the party has actually learned. Knowing a secret as a player doesn't require playing a character with no opinions about the clues in front of them.

The others may want to know that you have prior familiarity, without hearing which scenes you remember. The GM's permission settles their willingness to run for you; it doesn't automatically tell the rest of the table what to expect.

Don't make the GM promise to rewrite every secret for your benefit. Ask whether this particular campaign still offers enough enjoyment through the characters and group, even when some discoveries won't be new to you.

Yes. If you need a completely unfamiliar mystery to have fun, accepting this invitation and waiting for the GM to transform it would set both of you up badly. Familiarity can be workable without being the right fit for every player.

Join the discussion

More in Gaming